Joel McHale seems like a guy who'd be into the supernatural. Sure, he'd crack a few jokes about the sexual nature of abductions and the stereotyped appearance of aliens, but we'd bet a few moon rocks on the idea that he's open to the extraterrestrial.
His newly-announced guest character on The X-Files, Tad O'Malley, who is the anchor of a popular conservative Internet news network: ehh not so much.
Despite FOX's reassurance that O'Malley will actually serve as an ally to Mulder, we're not entirely convinced. As a result, we've compiled six gifs that will predict his character's skeptical reactions to all things paranormal. Check them out below and be sure to sound off on whether or not you think these will be accurate!